Don’t believe the great reviews for this place. It’s just a greasy spoon. I had breakfast there on a recent Saturday morning while passing through Carlisle. While the service was fine, the food was way below par for a diner. The scrambled eggs were just okay, nothing special, the bacon was greasy and rubbery, and the potatoes were room temperature and plain. The English muffin was untoasted and also room temperature, and the butter that came on the side was margarine. The coffee was exactly what you expect from diner coffee: weak, watery and bland. All this for a mere $13 with tip. Tripadvisor rates this as the top diner in Carlisle and the #6 overall restaurant in the area, but don’t believe it. It’s just crummy diner food, and rather disappointing diner food at that.
